In Season 4, Episode 8 of the Work Hard, Play Hard & Give Back podcast, host Mike Litzner sits down with longtime East Meadow real estate attorney Ted Rosenthal to examine contract expectations, "on or about" closing dates, and why direct phone communication remains essential for smooth Long Island transactions.
Key Episode Takeaways:
- An "on or about" closing date is a flexible target rather than a guaranteed deadline or a strict 30-day rule under New York law.
- Early alignment among the real estate agent, attorney, title company, and lender resolves title or boundary issues weeks before closing.
- Picking up the phone instead of relying solely on texts or emails prevents misunderstandings and supports clients through emotional moves and estate sales.
Four Decades of Community Law Practice in East Meadow
Ted Rosenthal, partner at Rosenthal, Curry & Kranz, traces his legal roots to his father, Jerry Rosenthal, who established his East Meadow practice in 1963 and closed Mike Litzner's very first real estate sale in 1984. After beginning his career in real estate litigation in The City, Ted joined his father's firm in 1988 to focus on community-centered transactional law, estate planning, and residential closings.
Following the 2008 housing downturn, the firm deliberately diversified its workload so that residential real estate accounts for roughly half of its practice alongside business transactions and estate settlements. Across every division, Rosenthal prioritizes human connection by maintaining a live receptionist and returning every client call promptly.
"Picking up the phone—I don't think there's anything that can replace it. When you're talking about the emotional side of moving or settling an estate, a direct conversation builds trust in a way an email or text never can." — Ted Rosenthal
Understanding "On or About" Closing Dates and Contract Pitfalls
One of the most frequent misconceptions in New York real estate involves the contract phrase "on or about" when setting a closing date. Rosenthal clarifies that "on or about" acts as a target timeframe rather than a strict legal deadline, and contrary to common belief, it does not automatically mean 30 days under the law.
Because moving is consistently ranked among life's most stressful events, agents must educate buyers and sellers on realistic timelines before contracts are drafted. When agents set accurate expectations upfront and alert attorneys to hard moving deadlines early, legal counsel can structure contract provisions properly to protect the client.
Teamwork at the Closing Table and Giving Back to East Meadow
Smooth 30-to-45-minute closings occur when the real estate agent, attorney, mortgage officer, and title company communicate proactively from the start of the transaction. Identifying potential complications—such as an out-of-possession fence or open title item—early in the process provides ample time to resolve issues without delaying the closing date.
Beyond legal practice, Rosenthal helped incorporate the Heart of American Homes Foundation, which has raised over $800,000 with 100% of funds directed back into local communities. A former president and lifetime board member of the East Meadow Chamber of Commerce, he also founded Friends for a Beautiful East Meadow, supports East Meadow Kiwanis, and has spent 20 years mentoring students at Woodland Middle School through the Nassau County Bar Association.
"In a real estate transaction, you have a seller who wants to sell and a buyer who wants to buy. Our job as attorneys is to advocate for our client while keeping an open mind so we can get everyone across the finish line." — Ted Rosenthal
Planning Your Next Long Island Real Estate Move
Whether preparing to sell a family home in Nassau County or purchasing your next residence on Long Island, partnering with experienced local professionals keeps your transaction on schedule. To connect with local agents in the area, visit the Coldwell Banker American Homes East Meadow office.
Homeowners considering a sale can request an initial property value estimate using the CB Estimate Home Valuation tool. Prospective buyers comparing neighborhoods and affordability across Long Island can explore the CB MoveMeter application, or browse additional episodes on the main CBAM Homes Blog Index.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does an "on or about" closing date legally mean in a New York real estate contract?
An "on or about" closing date serves as a target timeframe rather than a strict legal deadline or an automatic 30-day extension. Because the phrase carries legal flexibility, neither party can immediately hold a down payment solely because the target date passes without early legal preparation.
How can real estate agents and attorneys prevent last-minute surprises before a closing?
Agents and attorneys prevent late delays by clarifying client timelines upfront and communicating directly with title companies and lenders at the start of the transaction. Addressing potential boundary or title issues early provides sufficient time to resolve them before scheduling the closing table.
Why does Ted Rosenthal emphasize direct phone conversations over texting and email during real estate deals?
Direct phone calls prevent misinterpretations and help navigate the high emotional stress clients experience when buying, selling, or settling an estate. Speaking one-on-one builds trust and allows attorneys and agents to reach practical compromises quickly.
RSS Feed
